Menominee Comes Up Short In State Semifinals Against Ithaca

GAYLORD---This time, there was no last-minute miracle for the Menominee Maroons football team. The Maroons battled the Ithaca Yellowjackets all afternoon in the MHSAA Division Seven state semifinals Saturday in Gaylord, with the Yellowjackets advancing to Ford Field with a 34-26 win over Menominee.

In a back-and-forth game, Menominee's last gasp pass from U.P. Dream Team quarterback Dylan Beal on fourth down inside Ithaca territory landed incomplete with 30 seconds to play ended a remarkable Maroons season.

Unlike previous playoff wins that happened in remarkable fashion, the Maroons came home across the Mackinac Bridge Saturday night with no plan to go back across that bridge down to Ford Field. Instead, Ithaca will go to the state finals for the first time since 2017.

“Obviously, I am very proud of everybody who was on this field today,” Menominee Coach Chad Brandt said. “It was a battle right till the ball hit the turf on the final play. We just came up short, and it doesn't feel good when you come up short. We were just a couple plays away from making the difference the other way.”

Menominee led, 20-14, at halftime, before the Yellowjackets scored on a 57-yard touchdown run by quarterback Gibson Rondy to take a 21-20 lead. And Greyson Merchant, filling in on a play for Rondy after Rondy got poked in the eye, scored on a ten-yard run to make it 27-20. Ithaca missed the two-point play, so it stayed 27-20.

The Maroons put together a nice drive to stay alive, and the recently-awarded Mr. U.P. Football, Jackson Myszak, scored a one-yard touchdown on fourth down to cut it to a 27-26 deficit. Beal's pass for the two-point play, though, was incomplete.

The Maroons defense could not stop Ithaca on the next possession. The Yellow Jackets methodically went down the field, and Rondy scored on a five-yard run. Ithaca chose to kick the extra point this time, and made it, making it a 34-26 game.

The Maroons used the final few minutes to march down the field, converting a big third down play near midfield, but a penalty put them in a rough spot in the closing seconds. That 4th and 8 pass fell incomplete, ending the Maroons season with a 11-2 record.

Menominee had most of the statistics in their favor. They had double the number of first downs (24-12), dominated time of possession, and had nearly 400 yards of offense. But the U.P. Team of the Year did not have one statistic: the final score.

Rondy ran for 177 yards and three touchdowns for Ithaca (12-1).

Myszak had three touchdown runs and 75 yards rushing. Beal threw for 225 yards and a touchdown (to Talan Woods), and Cole Barstow ran for 108 yards on the ground in a losing effort.